SUCCESS STORY

New South Wales

Downing Centre Local Court – Apprehended Personal Violence Order Withdrawn Before Contested Hearing

EAS Legal represented a client named as the defendant in an Apprehended Personal Violence Order application in the Downing Centre Local Court. Although APVO proceedings are civil in nature, a final order can carry significant consequences for a person’s reputation, employment and personal life, and our client was determined to defend the application. Rather than waiting for a defended hearing, our team undertook a detailed analysis of the applicant’s evidence and identified significant concerns, including material that appeared to involve hearsay, inadmissible opinion evidence, and evidence of questionable reliability. We prepared and served a Notice of Defended Position setting out these deficiencies, and advised that our client would seek costs on the basis that the application appeared to have been commenced and maintained contrary to section 49A of the Crimes (Domestic and Personal Violence) Act 2007 (NSW). Following our correspondence and after obtaining independent legal advice, the applicant withdrew the application in its entirety, with no final order made and no defended hearing required. By resolving the matter early, our client avoided the stress, uncertainty and expense of contested proceedings.

APVO | EAS Legal
  • Apprehended Personal Violence Order (APVO)

Case Overview

Charge: APVO

Client: Anonymous Client

Court Location: Downing Centre Local Court

At EAS Legal, we recently represented a client before the Downing Centre Local Court who had been named as the defendant in an Apprehended Personal Violence Order (APVO) application.

While APVO proceedings are civil in nature, a final order can have significant consequences for a person’s reputation, employment and personal life. Our client was determined to defend the application and instructed us that the allegations did not accurately reflect what had occurred.

Rather than waiting for the matter to proceed to a defended hearing, our team immediately undertook a detailed analysis of the applicant’s evidence.

Our Approach

As part of our review, we identified a number of significant evidentiary concerns, including material that appeared to involve:

  • Hearsay evidence
  • Opinion evidence that was unlikely to be admissible
  • Evidence that raised serious questions as to its reliability

Following our analysis, we prepared and served a Notice of Defended Position, clearly outlining the deficiencies in the applicant’s case.

We also advised that, should the proceedings continue, our client would be seeking costs on the basis that the application appeared to have been commenced and maintained contrary to the obligations imposed under section 49A of the Crimes (Domestic and Personal Violence) Act 2007 (NSW).

Given the issues identified, we urged the applicant to obtain urgent independent legal advice before continuing with the proceedings.

The Outcome

Following receipt of our correspondence and after obtaining legal advice:

  • The APVO application was withdrawn in its entirety
  • Our client did not have to endure a defended hearing
  • The proceedings concluded without a final order being made

By resolving the matter at an early stage, our client avoided the significant stress, uncertainty and expense associated with contested court proceedings.

Why This Result Matters

Not every APVO application should proceed to a final hearing.

Early and careful examination of the available evidence can expose significant legal and evidentiary issues that fundamentally affect the strength of an application. In appropriate cases, identifying those issues early and communicating them effectively can lead to a matter being resolved without the need for lengthy litigation.

This case demonstrates the importance of:

  • Prompt legal advice;
  • Careful analysis of the evidence;
  • Strategic early intervention; and
  • Taking a proactive approach to protecting a client’s interests before a defended hearing becomes necessary.

At EAS Legal, we understand that defending an Apprehended Personal Violence Order can have far-reaching personal and professional consequences. Our focus is always on identifying the most effective strategy to achieve the best possible outcome while minimising unnecessary stress and legal costs for our clients.

Defending an APVO?

If you have been served with an Apprehended Personal Violence Order (APVO) or another protection order application, obtaining experienced legal representation early can make a significant difference to the outcome of your matter.

EAS Legal regularly represents clients in defended intervention order and APVO proceedings across New South Wales and Victoria, providing strategic advice and strong advocacy from the earliest stages of a case.

1800 117 533
www.easlegal.com.au

EAS Legal – Strategic Criminal & Intervention Order Lawyers. Proven Results.

Facing Similar Charges?

Don’t let a criminal charge destroy your future. Our experienced team has the expertise and track record to fight for the best possible outcome in your case.

GET IMMEDIATE HELPBOOK CONSULTATION

24/7 LAWYER NUMBER

1800 117 533

Our Recent Wins

easlegal

At EAS Legal, our team will ensure that you are provided with the most experienced and trusted advice, always.

QUICK LINKS
Immigration Law | Family Law Werribee | Family Law Brisbane | Family Law Geelong | Family Law Ballarat | Family Law Newcastle | Family Law Bacchus Marsh | Family Law Bendigo | Criminal Law Newcastle | Criminal Law Werribee | Criminal Law Geelong | Criminal Law Brisbane | Family Law Gold Coast | Family Law Sunshine Coast

1800 117 533

WERRIBEE
Suite 2, 18 Synnot St, Werribee VIC 3030

GEELONG
Suite 3, Ground Floor/200 Malop St, Geelong VIC 3220

NEWCASTLE
17 Bolton St, Newcastle NSW 2300

BRISBANE
Level 6 200 Adelaide Street, Brisbane QLD 4000

MELBOURNE
Southern Cross, Level 2/696 Bourke St, Melbourne VIC 3000

Seals_Finalists_Criminal Partner of the Year
Awards Recognition
Lawyers Weekly Parter of the year awards 2026 finalist. Criminal partner of the year silver badge

This website is owned and operated by Elbob & Stephenson Pty Ltd and the legal professionals provide their legal services through the firm trading as EAS Legal